Who or That: Understanding Relative Pronouns.

I. Introduction

Language is a dynamic and ever-evolving entity, with its intricacies adding depth and clarity to our communication. In the vast realm of English grammar, understanding the nuances of language can significantly impact how we convey our thoughts. One such nuance lies in distinguishing between “who” and “that” as relative pronouns, and it’s this distinction that we’ll explore in our discussion.

A. Explanation of the topic: “Who vs. That” When constructing sentences, it’s essential to choose the right words to describe the relationships between nouns and their relative clauses. “Who” and “that” are two such words, often used interchangeably. However, understanding when to employ each one can greatly enhance our ability to convey information effectively.

B. Importance of understanding the difference The choice between “who” and “that” might seem subtle, but it carries immense weight in language precision. By delving into the differences between these pronouns, we can master the art of linguistic clarity. A nuanced choice can lead to more accurate, informative, and engaging writing.

C. Overview of what will be covered in the outline In this essay, we’ll embark on a journey through the realms of “who” and “that.” We’ll examine their definitions, explore their proper usage, delve into key distinctions between the two, and offer additional tips to facilitate accurate and confident selection. By the end of this exploration, you’ll be well-equipped to wield “who” and “that” with finesse, elevating your command of language.

Join us as we unravel the intricacies of “Who vs. That” and pave the way for more precise and effective communication.

Explanation:

“Who” and “that” are not pronouns on their own but are used as relative pronouns in specific contexts. Relative pronouns are used to introduce relative clauses, which provide more information about a noun in a sentence. Here’s a breakdown:

• “Who” is a relative pronoun used to refer to people or, in some cases, named animals. It introduces a relative clause that provides additional information about the person or animal.
• “That” is a relative pronoun used to refer to both people and things. It is typically used in restrictive clauses (clauses that are essential to the meaning of the sentence) to provide more information about the noun.

So, while “who” and “that” are not pronouns by themselves, they function as relative pronouns when used in the context of a sentence to create relative clauses.

Using “Who”:

1. The doctor who treated my mother was very compassionate.
2. Do you know the person who won the Nobel Prize?
3. She is the teacher who inspired me to pursue a career in education.
4. The artist who painted this masterpiece is internationally renowned.
5. The neighbor who lives next door is always ready to help.
6. The actor who starred in the movie is attending the premiere.
7. The athlete who set the world record will be interviewed.
8. I met a scientist who conducts groundbreaking research in the field.
9. The girl who won the spelling bee received a trophy.
10. The friend who always makes me laugh is coming to visit.

Using “That”:

1. The book that I’m reading is a bestseller.
2. The car that we bought last year is a hybrid.
3. The house that I grew up in holds many cherished memories.
4. The movie that won the Academy Award is now streaming.
5. The data that we collected is essential for the project.
6. The laptop that he is using is the latest model.
7. The dog that saved the family from the fire is a hero.
8. The project that I’m working on requires careful planning.
9. The restaurant that we went to last night had delicious food.
10. The idea that sparked the innovation came from our team.

These examples showcase the usage of “who” and “that” in various contexts, highlighting their roles as relative pronouns in sentences.

II. Who

A. Definition of “who” as a relative pronoun:

• “Who” is a relative pronoun used to introduce relative clauses in sentences.
• It is primarily used when referring to people, but it can also be used for named animals.
• Relative clauses introduced by “who” provide additional information about the person or animal they refer to.

B. Usage for referring to people and, in some cases, named animals:

• “Who” is commonly used to refer to individuals, whether they are specific individuals or not.
• It can also be used to refer to named animals, treating them with a degree of personification.
• For example, “who” is appropriate in sentences such as “The woman who lives next door” or “The dog who won the show.”

C. Examples of “who” in sentences:

1. She is the teacher who inspired me to pursue my dreams.
2. Do you know the person who won the award?
3. The dog who rescued the family during the fire became a local hero.

D. Clarification on using “who” for both subject and object in sentences:

• “Who” can be used for both the subject and the object of a sentence, depending on the role it plays in the relative clause.
• When “who” functions as the subject, it often starts the relative clause and performs an action.
• When it serves as the object, it receives the action within the relative clause.

Example (Who as subject):

• “She is the writer who penned that bestseller.” (Who is the subject of the clause, performing the action of writing.)

Example (Who as object):

• “I met the woman who you recommended.” (Who is the object of the clause, receiving the recommendation.)

This section provides a comprehensive understanding of “who” as a relative pronoun, its usage for people and named animals, examples illustrating its usage, and how it can be used for both the subject and object within relative clauses.

III. That

A. Definition of “that” as a relative pronoun:

• “That” is a relative pronoun used to introduce relative clauses in sentences.
• It can refer to both people and things, making it more versatile than “who.”
• Relative clauses introduced by “that” provide additional information about the noun they modify.

B. Usage for referring to people and things, especially in restrictive clauses:

• “That” is typically used in restrictive clauses, which means the information provided is essential to the meaning of the sentence.
• It can refer to specific individuals, objects, or concepts, making it a versatile choice in various contexts.

C. Examples of “that” in sentences:

1. The book that I recommended is on the bestseller list.
2. The person that you met yesterday is my cousin.
3. The idea that sparked the innovation came from our team.

D. Mention of informal usage for people in less formal writing:

• In less formal writing or spoken language, “that” is often used to refer to people, although “who” may be preferred in more formal contexts.
• While this usage may be less strict, it’s essential to be aware of the context and audience to determine whether it’s appropriate.

Example:

• Informal: “The guy that we hired is really talented.” (Using “that” to refer to a person)
• Formal: “The person who we hired is highly skilled.” (Using “who” to refer to a person)

This section outlines the definition of “that” as a relative pronoun, its versatile usage for both people and things, examples illustrating its application, and a mention of its informal usage when referring to people in less formal writing or speech.

IV. Key Differences

A. A summary of the key distinctions between “who” and “that”:

• “Who” is primarily used to refer to people and, in some cases, named animals.
• “That” can refer to both people and things, making it more versatile.
• “Who” is often used in non-restrictive clauses that provide additional, non-essential information.
• “That” is typically used in restrictive clauses where the information is essential to the sentence’s meaning.

B. Emphasis on choosing the appropriate word based on the noun being modified:

• The key to using “who” or “that” effectively is to consider the nature of the noun they are modifying.
• When the noun is a person or a named animal, “who” is usually the more appropriate choice.
• When the noun is an object, concept, or the context demands a restrictive clause, “that” is often the better option.

Examples:

• “The scientist who discovered the cure for the disease received an award.” (Using “who” to refer to a person)
• “The data that we collected is crucial for our research.” (Using “that” to refer to data in a restrictive clause)

This section summarizes the key distinctions between “who” and “that,” highlighting their respective usages and emphasizes the importance of selecting the appropriate word based on the nature of the noun being modified.

V. Additional Tips

A. Guidance on using “who” when referring to people and “that” when referring to things:

• To maintain clarity and precision in your writing, follow the general guideline of using “who” when referring to people and “that” when referring to things.
• This approach helps ensure that you’re using the most suitable relative pronoun for the context.

B. Emphasis on consistency within a text or document:

• Consistency is key to maintaining the flow and coherence of your writing. Once you choose either “who” or “that” for a specific context, stick with that choice throughout your text or document.
• Avoid switching between the two, as inconsistency can confuse your readers.

C. Context-awareness and the importance of understanding when information is essential:

• Always be aware of the context in which you’re using “who” or “that.” Understanding the level of importance of the information you’re providing is crucial.
• In restrictive clauses (where the information is essential), “that” is often the better choice. In non-restrictive clauses (where the information is additional but not crucial), “who” might be preferred.
• Consider the impact on the sentence’s meaning and adjust your choice accordingly.

Example:

• “The document that contains confidential information must be secured.” (Using “that” for an essential, restrictive clause)
• “Our colleague, who recently won an award, is an asset to the team.” (Using “who” for non-restrictive information)

By adhering to these additional tips, you can enhance your writing by selecting the appropriate relative pronoun and ensuring consistency in your usage. Understanding the importance of information in context is also vital for effective communication.

VI. Conclusion

In the world of language and communication, the nuances of grammar often hold the key to precision and clarity. The distinction between “who” and “that” in relative clauses is a prime example of how a subtle choice can significantly impact the effectiveness of your messages. Understanding this difference is not a mere exercise in adhering to grammatical rules but a means to accurately convey information. As you embark on your journey to master “Who vs. That,” I encourage you to put this knowledge into practice in your writing. Consistent and appropriate use of these relative pronouns will sharpen your communication skills, allowing you to express your thoughts with greater accuracy and eloquence. Ultimately, by honing your grasp of these linguistic subtleties, you empower yourself to connect more effectively with your audience, fostering clarity and precision in your communication.

Test your Knowledge

Instructions: Fill in each blank with either “who” or “that” to complete the sentence correctly.

1. The scientist ____ discovered the new planet was awarded a prestigious prize.
2. Do you know the person ____ will be the keynote speaker at the conference?
3. The car ____ I drive to work is getting old.
4. The book ____ I recommended last week has received rave reviews.
5. The neighbor ____ lives next door is always friendly.
6. I appreciate the friend ____ always supports me.
7. The actress ____ played the lead role in the movie is very talented.
8. This is the artist ____ artwork has been displayed in several museums.
9. The dog ____ saved the family during the storm is a hero.
10. The students ____ scored the highest on the test will receive awards.
11. The project ____ you proposed last month is now in progress.
12. The teacher ____ inspired many students to pursue their dreams is retiring.
13. The data ____ we collected is vital for our research.
14. She is the singer ____ is performing at the concert tonight.
15. The movie ____ we watched last night was quite entertaining.
16. The idea ____ led to the breakthrough was brilliant.
17. The musician ____ composed this piece is a genius.
18. The building ____ houses the museum is an architectural marvel.
19. The restaurant ____ we visited last week had delicious food.
20. The company ____ I work for is known for its innovative products.

Once you’ve filled in the blanks, you can check your answers to see how well you did!

Here’s the answer key for the fill-in-the-blank test:

1. who
2. who
3. that
4. that
5. who
6. who
7. who
8. whose
9. that
10. who
11. that
12. who
13. that
14. who
15. that
16. that
17. who
18. that
19. that
20. that

These answers should help you check your responses and understand how “who” and “that” are appropriately used in the sentences.

Related Subject:

Pronoun Exercise For ESL Students | Education (educationbe.com)

Relative Pronouns Exercises | PDF (scribd.com)